Discussion about this post

User's avatar
ChaiShalom18's avatar

Once upon a time I was a contributing writer to Jewish Currents. I left (and was politely thrown out) when new editors declared for rabid anti-Zionism instead of a largely labor oriented journal of recent decades. At the retirement party for the past editor/publisher, I met some of the new team. Arielle Angel, after several years at the helm, left as editor-in-chief but her mark is there and taken to even further extremes. Peter Beinart is a bourgeois crybaby whose American Jewish jealousy

of Israeli men is so obvious. The retirement party was shortly before Chanukah. One new young staffer excitedly said the new JC should have a Chanukah party. The new chief editor (whose ‘creative writing’ MFA’s were obviously not in historical scholarship) exclaimed that “the Macabees were fascists.” Being a historian, I quickly asserted that fascism is generally considered a modern movement and not applicable to ancient societies. That if it was being used metaphorically, it better described the actions of the imperialist invading Assyrian Empire rather than the invaded tiny Israeli kingdom. Before walking away, I turned to the young man, smiled and said: “Have your Chanukah party.”

A few weeks later they did. Unfortunately it was to be an anti-Zionist propaganda event advancing Jewish culture and tradition without Israel. This upcoming event is farther out on a limb than even I would have suspected. When the Stalinist / Maoists (all needing calendars) come for them at JC, let’s hope Israel will receive them, as they did the anti Zionist Bundists escaping Nazism and then Stalinism. One editor left when JC made such a travesty of itself after October 7. He knew they went too far and actually went to live in Israel to be an anti-Likud activist, joining masses of Israelis in that quest, instead of condemning them all simply as “Zionist colonizers.”

shalom / salaam

Liora Jacob's avatar

Sadly, the phenomenon of the self hating “kapo Jew” is not uncommon throughout Jewish history. Whether through profound ignorance or some deep seated psychological need (ie Stockholm Syndrome or outright mental illness) such individuals turn their backs on their own people, land, culture and history. What they never understand until it is too late is that there is no great success in being on the last train to Auschwitz.

No posts

Ready for more?