Education or Indoctrination? Unmasking Antisemitism in Diversity Initiatives

When Inclusion Excludes: How a Prestigious Conference Became a Platform for Hate

In early December 2024, the National Association of Independent Schools (NAIS) hosted its annual People of Color Conference (PoCC) in Colorado, drawing approximately 8,000 students and educators from private schools across the U.S. The event, intended to promote equity and justice, became embroiled in controversy due to reports of overt antisemitism that left Jewish attendees feeling marginalized and unsafe.

Allegations of Antisemitism

Several speakers, including Dr. Suzanne Barakat and Princeton Professor Ruha Benjamin, made statements perceived as antisemitic. Barakat reportedly accused Israel of "ethnic cleansing" and "genocide" while downplaying atrocities committed by Hamas on October 7, which killed 1,200 Israeli civilians. Benjamin's remarks were interpreted as promoting a one-sided pro-Palestinian narrative, alienating Jewish participants. Some Jewish attendees concealed symbols of their faith or left the conference early.

Institutional Response

In response, NAIS President Debra Wilson apologized and pledged reforms, but critics argued the actions were insufficient, highlighting concerns about neglecting antisemitism in diversity and inclusion efforts. Jewish participants have called for clearer measures to prevent hate speech and ensure Jewish voices are included in conversations about equity and justice.